Müssen Frauen anders trainieren als Männer

Do women need to train differently than men?

So the days when women were the odd ones out at the gym are officially over. According to a 2019 survey by Allensbach Market and Media Analysis, a whopping 46 percent of all German gym members are female. - And yet there is still a lot of uncertainty about one crucial question: Do women need to train differently than men?

No More Cardio-Only Workouts

For decades, the typical female gym member was seen in one section of the gym above all others: the cardio area. Most women apparently joined the gym exclusively to spend hours on the stepper or Stairmaster. To burn calories, lose fat, lose weight, "tone up," and sculpt their bodies. Strength training with machines or even free weights was reserved for men—the fear of uncontrollably growing unwanted, unladylike bulges of muscle was simply too great.

Fortunately, more and more women today are realizing that pure cardio training does not lead to the dream body of fitness models. Those who do exclusively endurance sports will not come any closer to the beautiful buttocks and toned arms of the magazine cover models, but will instead actively work toward a lean, gaunt look.

The foundation for toning and body sculpting is nothing more than building muscle while simultaneously reducing body fat. And that requires weight training, for both women and men!

 

 

Women, Do It Like Men: Get Under the Bar!

The training goals of men and women are often different. While men go to the gym to gain weight and build muscle, female exercisers generally aim for a lean body with at most slightly visible muscle definition. And yet, the same approach is recommended for both sexes.

Progressive Weight Training

Women should also focus on progressive weight training. This means that the demands of the workout should be continuously increased: heavier weights, more repetitions with the same weight, shorter rest periods, etc. Only this will stimulate the muscle to adapt and thus also to grow. Those who follow the same workout plan over and over again without increasing the demands may still see results as beginners, but will quickly plateau.

Don't Be Afraid of Heavy Weights!

Unfortunately, many fitness trainers still write workout plans for their female clients using light dumbbells, which then have to be moved for 20 repetitions. Yet women can also train with heavy weights without any worries.

The idea that light weights and high repetitions build lean muscles, while heavy training builds huge muscle mass, is unfounded: Women's naturally low testosterone and high estrogen levels guarantee that uncontrolled muscle growth will not occur. Thus, training with heavy weights and sets of 5 to 10 repetitions also leads to a beautiful, athletic body that will certainly always remain feminine.

And Don't Be Afraid of the (Long) Barbell!

Training with free weights, especially with the barbell, still intimidates many women. Although machines are a good way for complete beginners in strength training to build a certain level of basic strength and develop a feel for their bodies. Even advanced athletes can incorporate machines into their workout plans again and again to isolate muscles.

In the long term, however, free weights should form the basis of the training. Dumbbell and barbell training is more efficient because the exercises challenge the body holistically and also train coordination in addition to muscle strength. It's also more fun!

 

 

Train Balanced

While many men perform a so-called "disco pump workout," in which only the upper body is trained, many women do exactly the opposite and focus primarily on their legs and buttocks. Training the torso is often limited to a few abdominal exercises. After all, a big biceps, broad back, or even visible chest muscles are something to avoid at all costs!

Regardless of gender and goals, balanced strength training should always be aimed for, in which all body parts are given equal attention. Neglecting or even completely omitting a muscle group is unhealthy and can lead to posture problems and wear and tear in the long term. And ultimately, it's not just about the beach body for men and women, but also about a healthy body.

But Wait: There Are Differences!

So, the training of women should not differ from that of men in its basic principles. Nevertheless, there are some physiological differences between the sexes that should be taken into account when designing the workout.

Women Are Particularly Enduring

 

Women generally have a particularly high proportion of Type 1 muscle fibers. These muscles, also called "red muscle fibers," are less capable of generating strength and performing fast, explosive movements. Instead, they are particularly enduring and recover quickly. This means for women:

 

  • Rest periods between sets can be kept shorter.
  • Weights can be chosen higher relative to maximum strength than for men. Example: A man can already be heavily challenged with 5 repetitions at 80% of the maximum weight he can move for one repetition. A woman can often still easily handle 5 repetitions at 90% of her maximum weight.
  • Instead of a highly split workout plan, a full-body workout is recommended, in which each muscle group is trained several times a week within a single session. Thanks to their good recovery, women are often fully capable again after just 24 to 48 hours!

 

Women Are More Flexible

… and that is both a curse and a blessing. A woman's higher estrogen level ensures more flexible joints—helpful in exercises like squats, which require good mobility in the hips and ankles.

However, greater mobility also results in reduced stability. If poor body control is added to this, the risk of injury increases massively. Women should therefore pay particular attention to controlled movement execution during training. Additional stabilizing exercises and strengthening the abdominal muscles and lower back are also important.

 

Strong Legs—Weak Upper Body

Legs and buttocks are naturally stronger than the upper body in almost all women, even without training. All the more fatal that many female gym-goers still focus on their lower bodies.

Of course: The societal beauty ideal encourages training the abs, legs, and buttocks rather than bicep curls and bench presses. But many women are simply dissatisfied with the appearance of their legs and try to counteract this through excessive strength training. Yet the gender-typical fat distribution, with a concentration on the thighs and buttocks, is often the cause. And fat loss can only be controlled through a good diet. - Strength exercises do not lead to local fat loss!

Conclusion on Training for Women

In principle, women can and should train just like men: with free weights, moderate to heavy loads, a steady increase in training load, and always holistically, that is, by taking every single muscle group into account. Due to the female hormonal balance, strength training designed this way does not lead to excessive muscle growth, but to a lean, athletic figure that is likely to meet the ideal conceptions of most women.

Nevertheless, there are subtle differences between men and women: Thanks to their muscle structure, women can recover faster from exertion and therefore train more frequently and with shorter rest periods between sets. Women are more flexible than men and should therefore perform strengthening and stability exercises to prevent injuries. Since women are almost always stronger in their lower bodies than in their shoulders, arms, and backs, the classic abs, legs, and buttocks workout is suboptimal.